Back

Top 10 Must-Try Italian Restaurants in NYC 2023

Dining Guide June 24, 2025

Experience the Best of Italian Cuisine in NYC

New York City is renowned for its diverse and vibrant dining scene, and Italian cuisine holds a special place in the hearts of many New Yorkers. From cozy trattorias to upscale ristorantes, NYC offers a plethora of Italian dining experiences that cater to every taste. With the help of TableTurn.nyc, you can secure reservations at these highly sought-after restaurants, ensuring a memorable dining experience.

1. Carbone

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Carbone, located in Greenwich Village, is a celebrated Italian-American restaurant by chefs Mario Carbone and Rich Torrisi. Known for its throwback to mid-20th-century dining, Carbone has become a staple in NYC's Italian dining scene.

Signature Dishes

Famous for its Spicy Rigatoni Vodka and Veal Parmesan, Carbone delivers on classic flavors with a modern twist.

Ambiance and Decor

The restaurant exudes a retro vibe, with red leather banquettes and tuxedoed waitstaff, offering a nostalgic dining experience.

Reservation Tips

Reservations are highly competitive; use TableTurn.nyc to monitor and secure a spot.

2. L'Artusi

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Opened by Gabe Thompson, L'Artusi in the West Village is known for its modern Italian fare and exceptional wine program.

Signature Dishes

Notable dishes include the Ricotta Gnudi and Olive Oil Cake, showcasing fresh ingredients and bold flavors.

Wine Program

The extensive wine list features selections from both Italian and New World vineyards, curated to complement the menu perfectly.

Reservation Tips

Weekdays are less crowded; book through TableTurn.nyc for easier access.

3. Via Carota

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Via Carota, crafted by chefs Jody Williams and Rita Sodi, is a beloved West Village spot offering rustic Italian dishes.

Signature Dishes

The Cacio e Pepe and Insalata Verde are must-tries, reflecting the chefs' dedication to simplicity and flavor.

Ambiance and Decor

The cozy, rustic decor makes it a perfect spot for a relaxed meal with friends or family.

Reservation Tips

No reservations are taken; arrive early or use TableTurn.nyc for updates on wait times.

4. Marea

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Marea, led by chef Michael White, is an upscale seafood-focused Italian restaurant near Central Park.

Signature Dishes

The Fusilli with Red Wine Braised Octopus is a standout, offering a unique blend of flavors and textures.

Ambiance and Decor

The elegant setting, complete with white tablecloths and sophisticated decor, provides a luxurious dining experience.

Reservation Tips

Book well in advance, or utilize TableTurn.nyc for last-minute openings.

5. Il Buco Alimentari & Vineria

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Located in NoHo, this Italian eatery combines a market, bakery, and restaurant, offering an authentic Italian experience.

Signature Dishes

The house-made Salumi and Pasta are highlights, made with meticulously sourced ingredients.

Ambiance and Decor

Rustic charm and communal tables create a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Reservation Tips

Weekday lunches are less busy; use TableTurn.nyc for dinner bookings.

6. Osteria Morini

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Chef Michael White's Osteria Morini in SoHo offers a taste of Northern Italy with a focus on the Emilia-Romagna region.

Signature Dishes

Try the Cappelletti with Truffle Butter for an indulgent pasta option.

Ambiance and Decor

The rustic decor and open kitchen create a lively yet intimate dining experience.

Reservation Tips

Use TableTurn.nyc to find weekend dinner slots.

7. Babbo

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Opened by chef Mario Batali, Babbo in Greenwich Village remains a favorite for its inventive Italian menu.

Signature Dishes

The Beef Cheek Ravioli and Black Spaghetti are iconic dishes that have stood the test of time.

Wine Program

An impressive selection of Italian wines complements the menu beautifully.

Reservation Tips

Consider early evening reservations; TableTurn.nyc can help secure a table.

8. Lupa

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Another gem from Mario Batali, Lupa Osteria Romana in the West Village offers Roman-style trattoria dining.

Signature Dishes

The Bucatini All'Amatriciana and Saltimbocca are crowd-pleasers.

Ambiance and Decor

Casual yet sophisticated, Lupa's ambiance is perfect for any occasion.

Reservation Tips

Off-peak times like late lunch may offer easier access; check TableTurn.nyc for availability.

9. Scarpetta

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Located in the NoMad neighborhood, Scarpetta by chef Scott Conant is famed for its modern Italian cuisine.

Signature Dishes

The Spaghetti with Tomato and Basil is a must-order, celebrated for its simplicity and flavor.

Ambiance and Decor

The sleek, contemporary decor provides a stylish backdrop for dining.

Reservation Tips

For special occasions, book through TableTurn.nyc to secure prime dining slots.

10. Locanda Verde

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Tribeca's Locanda Verde, headed by chef Andrew Carmellini, offers a homey take on Italian cuisine.

Signature Dishes

The Lamb Meatball Sliders and Lemon Ricotta Pancakes are highlights of the menu.

Ambiance and Decor

Combining rustic and modern elements, Locanda Verde offers a charming and comfortable setting.

Reservation Tips

Brunch is popular; use TableTurn.nyc to book your table in advance.

Related Recommendations

If you're exploring NYC's Italian dining scene, consider visiting these related restaurants: Le Bernardin, Daniel, and Eleven Madison Park for a taste of French-inspired cuisine with an Italian twist.

Summary

Discover the top 10 must-try Italian restaurants in NYC for 2023, featuring iconic chefs, signature dishes, and insider tips for securing reservations through TableTurn.nyc.

© 2024 Table Turn - All Rights Reserved