Back

Top 10 Must-Try Mediterranean Restaurants in NYC

Dining Guide March 3, 2025

Introduction

New York City, a melting pot of cultures, offers a diverse array of culinary experiences. Among them, Mediterranean cuisine shines with its vibrant flavors and emphasis on fresh ingredients. Here, we bring you a ranked list of the top 10 must-try Mediterranean restaurants in NYC, with insights into each establishment's unique offerings and tips for securing a reservation with the help of TableTurn.nyc.

1. Shuka

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Shuka, helmed by Chef Ayesha Nurdjaja, offers a delightful journey through the Mediterranean. Located in Greenwich Village, the restaurant is a sister to the popular Cookshop. Chef Nurdjaja's culinary prowess is evident in the vibrant dishes inspired by her travels across the Mediterranean.

Signature Dishes

The menu highlights include the Shuka Mezze Platter, featuring an array of dips and fresh pita, and the Lamb Tagine, a slow-cooked delight with apricots and almonds.

Price Points and Menu Highlights

With appetizers ranging from $10-$15 and entrees averaging around $25, Shuka offers a mid-range dining experience that doesn’t compromise on quality.

Ambiance and Decor

The restaurant's decor is a cozy blend of rustic and modern, with vibrant blues and greens evoking a Mediterranean seaside vibe.

Reservation Strategies and Tips

Reservations are highly recommended, especially for weekends. For a seamless booking experience, consider using TableTurn.nyc to secure your spot.

2. Balaboosta

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Led by Chef Einat Admony, Balaboosta in Nolita presents a sophisticated take on Mediterranean and Middle Eastern flavors. Chef Admony, an Israeli native, brings her heritage to the forefront with each dish.

Signature Dishes

Highlights include the Crispy Cauliflower with yogurt and mint, and the Harissa Chicken, which combines bold spices and tender meat.

Price Points and Menu Highlights

Expect to spend around $50 per person for a satisfying meal that captures the essence of the Mediterranean.

Ambiance and Decor

The intimate setting, with its warm lighting and eclectic decor, makes Balaboosta a perfect spot for both casual and special occasions.

Reservation Strategies and Tips

Due to its popularity, securing a reservation can be challenging. Use TableTurn.nyc to ensure you don’t miss out.

3. Ilili

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Located in the Flatiron District, Ilili is the brainchild of Chef Philippe Massoud. With Lebanese roots, Chef Massoud creates dishes that are both traditional and innovative.

Signature Dishes

The Duck Shawarma and Lamb Ribs are must-tries, showcasing the chef's ability to blend flavors masterfully.

Price Points and Menu Highlights

Ilili offers a luxurious dining experience with entrees averaging around $30, perfect for a special night out.

Ambiance and Decor

The restaurant's chic decor features high ceilings and elegant lighting, providing a sophisticated atmosphere.

Reservation Strategies and Tips

Ilili is a popular choice for both locals and tourists. Book through TableTurn.nyc for a hassle-free reservation experience.

4. Nur

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Nur, situated in the Flatiron District, is the collaborative effort of Chefs Meir Adoni and Gadi Peleg. The restaurant offers a modern twist on Middle Eastern cuisine.

Signature Dishes

Standouts include the Jerusalem Bagel with smoked salmon and the Lamb Neck Hummus, both of which exemplify the chefs' innovative approach.

Price Points and Menu Highlights

With entrees priced around $28, Nur offers a high-end dining experience that remains accessible.

Ambiance and Decor

The sleek, modern decor complements the creative dishes, making it an ideal spot for adventurous diners.

Reservation Strategies and Tips

Reservations are essential, and TableTurn.nyc can help you secure a table at this sought-after restaurant.

5. Café Mogador

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Since its opening in 1983, Café Mogador in the East Village has been a beloved staple for Moroccan and Mediterranean cuisine.

Signature Dishes

The Moroccan Tagine and Lamb Couscous are perennial favorites, offering authentic tastes at reasonable prices.

Price Points and Menu Highlights

With most entrees priced under $20, Café Mogador is a budget-friendly option for Mediterranean food lovers.

Ambiance and Decor

The casual, bohemian atmosphere makes it a great spot for both brunch and dinner.

Reservation Strategies and Tips

While reservations are not always necessary, they are recommended for weekend brunch. Use TableTurn.nyc to plan your visit.

6. Pylos

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Located in the East Village, Pylos offers a taste of Greece with an emphasis on authenticity and quality.

Signature Dishes

Enjoy the Moussaka and Spanakopita, both made with traditional Greek recipes.

Price Points and Menu Highlights

Entrees average around $24, making it a mid-range choice for Greek cuisine enthusiasts.

Ambiance and Decor

The charming decor, featuring hanging clay pots, transports diners to the Greek Isles.

Reservation Strategies and Tips

Reservations are recommended, and TableTurn.nyc can assist in securing a table.

7. Taverna Kyclades

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Known for its fresh seafood, Taverna Kyclades in Astoria is a favorite among locals for authentic Greek dishes.

Signature Dishes

The Grilled Octopus and Saganaki are must-tries, highlighting the restaurant's dedication to quality ingredients.

Price Points and Menu Highlights

With entrees ranging from $18-$30, it's a great spot for seafood lovers seeking authentic flavors.

Ambiance and Decor

The casual, family-friendly atmosphere is perfect for group dining.

Reservation Strategies and Tips

No reservations are accepted, so arrive early or use TableTurn.nyc for insider tips on the best times to visit.

8. Kish-Kash

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Chef Einat Admony's second entry on our list, Kish-Kash in Chelsea, focuses on North African flavors with a modern twist.

Signature Dishes

The Lamb Couscous and Roasted Cauliflower are standout dishes, showcasing the chef's flair for spices.

Price Points and Menu Highlights

Entrees are reasonably priced, averaging around $22, offering great value for the quality.

Ambiance and Decor

The casual, vibrant setting makes it a great choice for a relaxed meal.

Reservation Strategies and Tips

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends. Use TableTurn.nyc to book your table.

9. Ousia

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Located in Midtown, Ousia offers a contemporary twist on Greek and Mediterranean cuisine, led by the Livanos family.

Signature Dishes

Try the Spanakopita Flatbread and the Grilled Branzino for a taste of Greece in the heart of NYC.

Price Points and Menu Highlights

With entrees around $26, Ousia provides a modern dining experience at a reasonable cost.

Ambiance and Decor

The sleek, modern design with an open kitchen creates a vibrant dining environment.

Reservation Strategies and Tips

Reservations are advised. Let TableTurn.nyc help you secure your spot.

10. Amali

Chef Background and Restaurant History

Amali, located on the Upper East Side, combines Mediterranean and Greek influences with a focus on sustainability.

Signature Dishes

The Grilled Lamb Chops and the seasonal Risotto are highlights, emphasizing fresh, local ingredients.

Price Points and Menu Highlights

Entrees are priced around $28, reflecting the restaurant's commitment to quality and sustainability.

Ambiance and Decor

The elegant, rustic decor provides a warm and inviting atmosphere.

Reservation Strategies and Tips

Amali is popular for both lunch and dinner. Use TableTurn.nyc to secure a reservation.

Conclusion

From traditional flavors to modern interpretations, NYC's Mediterranean dining scene is as vibrant as ever. Each of these top 10 restaurants offers a unique experience, and with the help of TableTurn.nyc, you can ensure you won't miss out on these culinary delights. Book your table today and embark on a Mediterranean journey right in the heart of New York City.

Summary

Explore the vibrant flavors of the Mediterranean in NYC with our top 10 restaurant picks. Discover chef insights, signature dishes, and practical reservation tips. Let TableTurn.nyc help you secure a spot at these culinary hotspots.

© 2024 Table Turn - All Rights Reserved